I've only tried a few of their bears oils. Right now I'm using the eucalyptus one and this new high tide mack. While I really enjoy them both, I love that the high tide scent is downplayed a bit. For me, with the eucalyptus, I can only use that one when I'm staying in, as the scent is a lot, but i do enjoy it. The high tide on the other hand is perfect for going out. And they both have all the same stuff in them, just different scents, so they're both excellent for the skin underneath your beard. I highly recommend the high tide.