After going through all of the different oils in the sample pack, Highlander Mack was my favorite (with Revolutionary Mack being a close second). I know that the Roaring 20's Mack is their take on a barbershop scent but to my nose the Highlander is 100% "barbershop". To me it smells like smooth, warm shaving cream, a scoop of pomade and a dusting of talcum powder. The scent lasts a long time too. Definitely one for my short list of beard oils that I will order again.